FatFace, read closely: good cotton, easy returns, and a Fair Isle jumper that is mostly polyester

The short answer

For the cotton, yes. FatFace’s pure cotton hoodies, shirts and Breton tees are honest weekend clothes, and since it joined Next’s network an online order can be collected or returned free at hundreds of stores.¹² The knitwear is the problem. Several jumpers with Fair Isle or wool in their names turn out, on the label, to be mainly acrylic or polyester.³ Buy the cotton, read the composition of everything knitted, and do not pay full price for the latter.

Points in favour

The FatFace story, as the brand tells it, begins in 1988 with two friends running out of money in the Alps and printing sweatshirts to sell at night so they could ski by day; the name comes from La Face, a black run in Val d’Isère.⁴ The cotton is where that origin still shows. The Pure Cotton Hoodie is all cotton and well reviewed, if a little roomy by one buyer’s account, and the men’s Regular Fit Pure Cotton Shirt is all cotton too and comes in a long length as well as the regular.³ These are the clothes the brand was built on, and they remain the most dependable things it sells.

If you want a Fair Isle, buy one with the sheep still in it.

The second argument is logistical. FatFace now shares Next’s machinery, which means an order placed by ten at night can be collected free the next day from a FatFace shop or from any of Next’s several hundred stores, and returns go back free to either, without a label.¹² Sale items get the full twenty-eight days, which is not true at every rival. The women’s jeans come in four leg lengths across the new styles,⁵ and the Re-Skinned scheme takes back old FatFace clothes in any condition in exchange for a discount code. It is a well-organised shop that makes it easy to change your mind.

Reservations

The knitwear names do a great deal of work. A FatFace Fair Isle Crew Neck Jumper listed at M&S this autumn was two-thirds polyester, with acrylic most of the rest and a token twentieth of wool. The Fair Isle Jumper with Wool was two-thirds acrylic. The Wool Rich Cardigan contained less than half wool, the rest acrylic and polyester.³ None of this is hidden, exactly; the compositions are on the pages. But Fair Isle used to mean something about Shetland and sheep, and wool rich ought to mean more wool than not. The brand’s own knitwear care guide calls pilling normal.⁵ With these blends, it will be.

FatFace is a good place to buy cotton and a poor place to buy wool.

The service record is the other concern. FatFace’s Trustpilot score is high, helped by a brand that invites reviews and replies to nearly all the negative ones, but the one-star reviews from this October cluster tightly: orders that never arrived, items cancelled for lack of stock with the refund left for the customer to chase, and a reply described as a generic bot.⁶ There are also product complaints of a kind that suggest uneven manufacturing: a pair of trousers with one leg cut differently from the other, leggings that had become shinier and less stretchy. Several of the bad experiences were online; the shop staff are praised far more often.

The range, considered

Pure cotton hoodies, shirts and the Breton Tee Our choice This is the FatFace to buy. The Pure Cotton Hoodie and the men’s Regular Fit Pure Cotton Shirt are both all cotton, plainly cut, and reviewed warmly by the few buyers who have reviewed them so far.³ The Breton Tee and the Airlie sweatshirts belong to the same tradition, and the brand’s own Breton guide is cheerfully keen on the garment’s naval history.⁵ The caution is fit: the hoodie runs roomy for at least one reviewer, and another on Trustpilot found a fit so generous that she went down a size.

Women’s jeans and dungarees Also considered The women’s denim guide lists straight, wide, tapered, flared, bootcut and barrel fits and states that the new styles come in four leg lengths,⁵ which is more care than many brands at this price take. The dungarees (the Lewes and the Clayton) are a FatFace speciality and a cheerful one. The weakness is information: the guides say supersoft and breathable rather than giving stretch or cotton percentages, and the men’s guide lists five fits but no leg lengths. Check the product page before buying, and expect the softer denim to give.

Fair Isle and wool-named knitwear Not for us Read the label and walk past. The Fair Isle Crew Neck Jumper is mostly polyester with a twentieth of wool; the Fair Isle Jumper with Wool is mostly acrylic with a little alpaca for the story; the Wool Rich Cardigan is less than half wool.³ They are pretty and they will be warm enough, and the early reviews are kind. But the prices are those of wool knitwear, and the fibres are those of a supermarket jumper. If you want a Fair Isle, buy one with the sheep still in it.

Personal styling and the Re-Skinned trade-in Also considered Two services worth knowing about. Personal styling sessions can be booked online, though the page we read did not say whether they are free or where they happen.⁵ The Re-Skinned scheme takes up to three FatFace items in any condition, in a shop or by post, and returns a one-off discount code; the catch is a minimum spend on full-price items to use it, so the trade-in mainly works as an incentive to buy new.² The clothes it takes back are cleaned, mended and resold, and that part is admirable.

The business of buying

FatFace’s delivery and returns run through the same Next network as Joules. Free next-day collection covers most FatFace shops and Next’s several hundred stores for orders placed by ten at night, though the help pages exclude the Channel Islands, London Bridge and airport branches, and say timings cannot be guaranteed.¹ Home delivery carries a standard charge. Returns are accepted for twenty-eight days from receipt or purchase, full price and sale alike. Returning to a store costs nothing; booking an Evri collection or using a ParcelShop or locker costs a flat fee per parcel, deducted from the refund, and if the whole order goes back the delivery charge is refunded too.² Recent one-star reviews describe missing parcels and slow replies online,⁶ so for anything time-sensitive the store collection is the wiser choice. Student, key worker and military discounts are offered.

Where we land

FatFace is a good place to buy cotton and a poor place to buy wool. The hoodies, shirts, Bretons and jeans are sound, sensibly cut and easily returned at any Next. The knitwear, on the evidence of its own labels, trades heavily on names its fibres do not support, and the online service has had a rough autumn. Buy the cotton basics, collect them from a shop, check the composition of anything knitted, and keep the Fair Isle budget for a jumper that has met a sheep.

❦

Elsewhere

Notes and sources

1. FatFace help centre, ‘Can I have my order delivered to a store?’, read October 2026: free next-day delivery to most FatFace stores and Next’s 500-plus stores for orders before 10pm; Channel Islands, London Bridge and airport stores excluded.↩
2. FatFace help centre returns articles and Re-Skinned page, read October 2026: 28 days, full price or sale; free to FatFace or Next stores; Evri collection or drop-off £2.50 per parcel; £4.95 delivery refunded if the whole order is returned; Christmas purchases 16 September to 13 December 2026 returnable until 10 January 2027; Re-Skinned gives a 20% code with an £80 full-price minimum spend.↩
3. FatFace product pages on marksandspencer.com, read October 2026: Fair Isle Crew Neck Jumper 66% polyester, 29% acrylic, 5% wool; Fair Isle Jumper with Wool 67% acrylic, 25% wool, 8% alpaca; Wool Rich Cardigan 45% wool, 35% acrylic, 20% polyester; Pure Cotton Hoodie and Regular Fit Pure Cotton Shirt 100% cotton. FatFace’s own product pages refused automated access.↩
4. FatFace ‘Our Story’ page, read October 2026: founded 1988 by Tim and Jules; named after La Face, a black run in Val d’Isère.↩
5. FatFace guides read October 2026: women’s and men’s denim fit guides (women’s new styles in S, R, L and XL leg lengths), knitwear care guide, Breton blog, dungarees blog, personal styling page.↩
6. Trustpilot, uk.trustpilot.com/review/www.fatface.com, read October 2026: TrustScore 4.5 from about 117,600 reviews; FatFace invites reviews and replies to 99 per cent of negative ones; one-star filter read for October 2026 complaints.↩

Filed under the Wardrobe desk